September 2, 2015
Eddie is a counselor and a speaker. He can be reached on Twitter @EdwardorEddie or at eddiekaufholz.com. Additionally, he can be heard weekly on the RELEVANT Podcast.
[Editor’s note: To participate in our weekly advice column, submit your questions here and watch this space each Wednesday.]
I am 28 and finally doing work that is incredibly satisfying to me. Additionally, I’ve started to feel called to more areas both inside and outside of my work that I’m just really excited about. Here’s the thing though: People around me are dropping subtle (and not so subtle) hints that maybe it’s time to start thinking about having children. Also, many of my friends are already on their first, second and even third (!) kid.
I guess what I’m asking you for is some perspective on the tension I’m feeling of not wanting to "settle down" and have kids yet, but rather focus solely on the work I’m feeling called to do.
Thank you,
Childless and Happy
Dear Happy,
Here’s the answer: You don’t have to have children. There is no biblical mandate to procreate, and God won’t be smiting you for a lack of progeny. And while I’m not denying that kids are great and certainly gifts from God—they aren’t the gift or the goal in life.
The goals in life, and the actions that are mandated of us as followers of Jesus have very little to do with what we make, the work we do or even the children we have. What’s required of us is to lean into the work of justice, mercy and humility. And what should order our steps is a deep concern for our neighbors and a palpable love of God our Father. Those are the things that matter, and those are things God has asked us to concern ourselves with. Everything else—like the food we eat, the clothes we wear, the children we may or may not have, the jobs we love and everything else—is all in God’s control, timing and purview.
If you’re genuinely feeling like God isn’t calling you to parenthood right now, then trust that—and don’t overthink it.
So if you’re pursuing God and doing all you can to put one foot in front of the other and walk toward Him, then the “when/if I should have kids” question is out of your hands. Your job is obedience, God’s job is babies (and everything else). If you’re genuinely feeling like God isn’t calling you to parenthood right now, then trust that—and don’t overthink it. If God knows the face of your (possible future) child, then trusting in His sovereignty means you’ll know it, as well.
That being said, there’s more to consider than this truth. Allow me to share two thoughts that I think may prove helpful for you:
People Are Not Going to Understand You
There is almost nothing as intense as a parent with an opinion, much less a parent with an opinion and without a mental filter. If you want to have some fun, the next time you’re around a group of parents, ask them where their kids are going to school (home, public, private, co-op, etc.). The opinions will fly and some of them will be less than tactful. It should be an entertaining dog-fight to watch.
Parents care—or should I say, we care—because we are deeply invested in our children. The decisions we make on their behalf matter a great deal, and we feel the pressure to get it right and to make sure others do as well. And sometimes, some of us have a hard time keeping to ourselves that which we feel so passionate about.
What you’re starting to hear are the early whispers of parents who think you’re getting it wrong by not being a parent. Are you wrong? No, you aren’t. But for some, that’s just not a reality they can see. I see it, because for a long time I couldn’t imagine being a parent.
But also, as I grow closer and closer to my daughters, I have to say there is a part of me that just wants to say, “Trust me, kids are the best!” But that’s me, not you. You have a single voice to listen to (God) and a single truth to pursue (God again). Grace will be required for people around you as you do what’s right in God’s economy, while slightly counter-cultural in your community of parents.
Revisit Your Decision
As I mentioned earlier, I wasn’t always jazzed about being a parent. I certainly didn’t grow up wanting kids, and as I got older that feeling didn’t change. I can remember saying during my early years of marriage that I thought “kids would kind of wreck my life.” And, you know what, they may have back then—in a way. Because then—like you—I just wasn’t called to be a parent. I wasn’t particularly anti-kid, and I loved my sweet nieces, but for me, parenthood just wasn’t something God had on my radar.
Over time, that changed. And what was at one point a hesitation about having children because I didn’t have God’s clarity, shifted gradually to a fear of having kids because I was afraid I’d be a terrible dad.
Do you see the shift? I was trepidatious the whole time, but at some point in the dance with God, the fear shifted from having children at all, to actually figuring out how to have children and love them well. With kids, and with many other things in my life, God’s clarity didn’t come in the form of a “no” turing into a “yes.” But rather a “no” turning into a fear that I needed to overcome and discover was a “yes.”
I’m not saying this will be your story, and I’m certainly not meaning to imply that the road to parenting is always a fearful one. But I am saying that for now, with the clarity you seem to have, I’d drop the conversation and trust God with what you know to be true.
However, I would also make it a habit to revisit the idea with God every once in a while to confirm that what you're thinking still aligns with what God’s planning. Maybe things will change and you’ll want to pursue adoption or birthing a child—or maybe things won’t change. But either way, I would take a cue from the whispering parents and just double check that what you’re feeling remains accurate.
Either way, be bold in what God has called you to do and press forward.
Kids or no kids, you’re doing a great job. Thanks for trusting me to have this conversation with you.
Warmly,
Eddie
Have a question? Good! Send an email to AskRELEVANT@relevantmagazine.com. All identifying information will be kept anonymous.
Recommended For You
View More in LifeMost Popular
Latest Slices
- > 'Making A Murderer' Co-Defendant Brendan Dassey's Conviction Gets Overturned
- > Cannes' Mayor Bans Women From Wearing Burkini at the Beach
- > Here’s The Lumineers’ New Song for the ‘Pete’s Dragon’ Soundtrack, ‘Nobody Knows’
- > Ayesha Curry Designed a Cool Looking Spatula with Proceeds Going to End Childhood Hunger
- > Nickelodeon Is Bringing Back ‘Rocko’s Modern Life’ for a TV Movie
10 Comments
I'm sorry but it seems the basic premise to the response to this woman is deeply flawed. There is a biblical mandate to procreate. Being fruitful and multiplying is part of the purpose that God created mankind. As his image bearers we are to fill the earth with offspring. Having children goes down to the very core for why we were created. You see this in Gen chapter 1 verse 28, and again after the flood in Gen 9:1 as God is refocusing mankind toward original purpose and design. Being fruitful and multiplying is also one of the ways God blesses people. That's one of the reasons why when you read scripture women were ashamed when they were barren. It was viewed as being a curse from God not to be able to have children. Psalm 127:3 says, Children are a gift from the Lord; they are a reward from him. What you are saying to God when you are closing yourself off to parenthood, is "God I don't want your blessing." Children are a blessing in many ways, but the true blessing comes, because they require you give yourself up for a higher purpose. As one commentator stated earlier, people say the desire not to have children is viewed as selfish...well it is. Especially for woman rejecting motherhood to pursue careers. God designed each sex uniquely and specifically to fill a role and function for the flourishing of all of creation. The fact that you are a woman, designed as the helper, intrinsically ties you to motherhood and childbearing. Our culture and society are promoting us away from the design that God intended and more toward a self indulgent life...being lovers of ourselves and our money (2 Tim 3:2). In this culture now its common for women give up motherhood in pursuit of career, and men give up career in pursuit of laziness and remaining child-like. Not wanting kids, is in essence a desire to live for yourself and your own convenience. Which is an anti-Christian ethic. Giving up yourself, being self-sacrificing is the attitude Christ Jesus had and desires for us to mirror. Its a worship issue...what do you worship more...convenience, or Christ? I was the anti-kid guy. I never wanted kids. Convenience was my god up until I saw my first child be born (which was totally unplanned). I was freaking out on the inside though I acted excited on the outside...I was freaking out because I thought my life was over. Then, the moment I saw my daughter's head as she was being born I became a different person. People who don't have kids can't understand the miracle that happens the moment you see your child born. That's why you are okay with not having them. A spiritual connection takes place at birth and you realize a love for someone you have never experienced before. For me, that day my daughter was born, the Holy Spirit began to reveal just how selfish I really was and take me on a journey. Now, four kids later, I can say I'm still not perfect, but light years from where I was. If it wasn't for my kids, I don't think I would even be married today, because my selfishness would have ruined my marriage. Children are a great gift, not because they make you feel good (that's also a selfish attitude) but because they help you be more like Jesus, and give you insight into the Father's love for us. God may not give you children, and that's okay, because it means he is calling you for a specific purpose...maybe to adopt...or maybe some other form of ministry. But for those who can have children and choose not to, you are missing out on an incredible blessing God wants to give you. I pray that you do not close yourself off to the idea, but surrender it to Jesus, and let the Holy Spirit lead your decisions, not our culture of convenience. And by the way...if you do decide to have kids I can promise once you have them you wouldn't trade them for the world. Even though some days it sounds like a really good idea :)!
I am so glad the author didn't go the "be fruitful and multiply" route! This is a great response.
For those who are tempted to go that route:
1. The verse actually says, "Be fruitful and multiply. Fill the earth and govern it." Mission accomplished!! There are 7 billion people in this world, many who don't have enough to eat or clean water to drink. Let's take care of the ones we have before we go pressuring other people to make more.
2. What if I told you... that we could interpret "Be fruitful and multiply" in a spiritual sense? Has your faith been fruitful? Has your church multiplied recently?
3. If Christians are still subject to the "Be fruitful and multiply" command in a physical sense, and if that mission hasn't been accomplished yet, then why the push towards singleness in the New Testament from both Paul and Jesus?
Let's focus on being fruitful spiritually before we pressure others to be "fruitful" physically.
Warped post-Christian thought is where you are at on your three points:
1. The numbers game: The truth is that people, not government produce wealth, but bad religion and bad government squander it. The poorest in Los Angeles live like kings to those living where 1 person in 1,000 square miles is the norm. Yours is the same failed argument that Socrates made- he thought there were too many back in his day. On another tangent, who told you 7 billion is enough? The Earth had that much or more when the flood of Noah took all but 8 of them away.
2. Spiritualizing Scripture at the expense of its literal meaning is a hallmark of liberalism. Secondary meaning never conflicts with the primary meaning in biblical hermeneutics. You pose a secondary meaning and place it at odds with its primary meaning.
3. Ah, another distortion and an deflection of the real message. Paul taught that sound doctrine included women marrying, giving birth, training their children, and honoring their husbands. Okay, let's rephrase that: the Holy Spirit moved Paul to teach us what sound doctrine is to look like. Paul also revealed the only time limiting the number of children for the Kingdom of God is permitted: when you serve with a singleness of heart (pun intended). If you want to focus on evangelism and not be distracted by a family, marriage is not for you. The other thing you tend to forget is that the early part of the ministry of the disciplines operated under the understanding that Jesus was returning within a few short years, which is why many of them sold their goods - something fine for the short term, but terrible when it turned into a long term wait due to Israel being cut off in unbelief. Which is why Paul later raised money for the poor saints in Jerusalem.
Yours is a false spirituality that recoils from sound doctrine.
You wrote, "Everything else—like the food we eat, the clothes we wear, the children we may or may not have, the jobs we love and everything else—is all in God’s control, timing and purview." This doesn't seem to match up with an answer of "yes, you can choose career over children" unless you are speaking to a single woman. If your answer is aimed at a married woman, then I hope she isn't "planning" whether or not to have children via birth control (which in most cases is an abortifacient and in no case is really "trusting God's control or timing" of the womb).
Biblically, a single woman may choose a career without qualms. A married woman, however, does have the Biblical mandate to be a woman who loves her husband, is a keeper of the home, and one who welcomes and trains her children. Does this mean she will never work outside the home? No, but she may have limited seasons to which she can devote her attention to such things. Colossians speaks of doing whatever we do with all our might for the Lord. If you want to remain "childless and happy" than Biblically, you choose to follow a path like the Apostle Paul (as a single person). Once you marry, however, you have entered a realm where God has much to say, and in the Bible that word is never, "Women, go have a career. I don't want you to have children." Though a marriage may not always naturally result in children, God's design for marriage is to bear fruit, and the natural fruit of a healthy, godly marriage is the blessing of children.
Is a woman's sole purpose and goal to be a mother? No, our sole purpose is to honor and glorify God. But when we take our wedding vows, the general calling we have entered into includes the realm of motherhood and should not be planned or delayed away in order that we might "do" things that are "intensely satisfying" to me. We do not glorify God by subverting His plan for the family. Period.
Very relevant discussion as the trend is to try to increase women's representation in the workplace. The author, however, diminishes the role of the Bible in this decision. 1) The Bible indicates marriage is normative for all people. It is the pre-Fall creation pattern set out for us. The blessing of Abraham was to be on all the families of the earth, which requires marriage, of course. Paul's desire in 1 Corinthians 7:7 does not mean he wants all to be single, but that he wishes all would have self-control as he does as that is the issue (see especially v6) he is addressing. 2) Normative does not mean that all must marry but not marrying must not serve self-centered interests. 3) The purpose of Christian marriage serves several purposes: companionship, protection, help in pursuing holiness, sexual enjoyment, and to have children and raise them to serve God. "Did he not make them one, with a portion of the Spirit in their union? And what was the one God seeking? Godly offspring. So guard yourselves in your spirit, and let none of you be faithless to the wife of your youth." Malachi 2:15 (ESV) 4) Wives clearly can conduct business (Proverbs 31), but Scripture indicates that such work should not be contrary to being keepers at home and personally raising children. (Titus 2:3-5).
Take advantage of singlehood and learn to love yourself. Marriage and babies are a game changer. Simple things like sleeping, eating lunch and watching your favorite movie become limited and sometimes unattainable. So make the best of this time. 10 Things To Do While You’re Single: http://www.happysonship.com/top-5-things-to-do-when-youre-single/


Top Comments
1
7
Lauren commented…
As a young woman with an amazing, God driven career I have faced this question often. The idea of walking with God, carefully and prayerfully submitting your decisions to Him, is one of the best pieces of advice I think there is to hear. As Christians our relationship with Him is the all important factor: not what other people think we should be doing and/or when. He paved the way for me, moving family off of my current horizon but placing me in an critical place to do His work. If I hadn't continued on my career path there are countless lives that I may never have been able to be a part of. I think as Christians we need to remember that we have no idea of what God's total vision is for ourselves, much less another person. Checking in on your still single or childless brother/sister in Christ should mean we encourage their relationship with God to grow. We shouldn't make obnoxious assumptions and/or judgements if s/he has not procreated at an "appropriate" time. For that matter, I would also like to point out that childless couple at your church may be suffering from infertility. Perhaps a tiny bit of empathy and humanity, you know those Christ like virtues we should be living daily, is called for.
1
3
Laura M Brewer commented…
I am so glad the author didn't go the "be fruitful and multiply" route! This is a great response.
For those who are tempted to go that route:
1. The verse actually says, "Be fruitful and multiply. Fill the earth and govern it." Mission accomplished!! There are 7 billion people in this world, many who don't have enough to eat or clean water to drink. Let's take care of the ones we have before we go pressuring other people to make more.
2. What if I told you... that we could interpret "Be fruitful and multiply" in a spiritual sense? Has your faith been fruitful? Has your church multiplied recently?
3. If Christians are still subject to the "Be fruitful and multiply" command in a physical sense, and if that mission hasn't been accomplished yet, then why the push towards singleness in the New Testament from both Paul and Jesus?
Let's focus on being fruitful spiritually before we pressure others to be "fruitful" physically.