Can You Be Loyal to God and Country?

On Memorial Day weekend, a former soldier explores the tension of honoring a warrior without honoring war.

Memorial Day is a time to remember those who have died in war. As a soldier-turned-pacifist, I have mixed feelings about the national holiday—and you should as well.

Originally known as Decoration Day, Memorial Day was inaugurated by freed black slaves in South Carolina honoring Union soldiers who died before the end of the Civil War. The day of May 30 was chosen specifically because it was not the anniversary of a battle. It was a day to mourn, to reflect and to move forward with the past in mind.

The National Holidays Act of 1971 moved Memorial Day to the last Monday in May, effectively reducing it to merely mark the onset of summer. In 2002, the Veterans of Foreign Wars issued a statement decrying the “nonchalant” observance of Memorial Day. No longer tied to a specific day of the month but a whole weekend, Memorial Day seems to have become an excuse to huddle around the grill or watch the Indianapolis 500. This is not, however, the origin of my mixed feelings.

As a veteran, I am a member of a particular (martial) community with which I strongly identify. When I became a Christian and laid down my weapon, I did not ask to leave the military. Though this might seem like I was not committed to the pacific convictions that emerged as a result of my conversion, Christian convictions should make us very uneasy about the supremacy given to war and those who fight therein. Does honoring warriors give unwarranted credence to war? I can say with confidence that it does not, but my confidence comes from knowing many of those who have fought, which is a luxury not every Christian (or American, for that matter) is afforded. Fewer and fewer are being asked to fight more and more while we share less and less in common with those who have served.

It takes no shortage of character to face the trials and tribulations of war. It certainly is hell, no doubt. Throughout history, war has been waged with the help of conscription—most recruits have been draftees. Today that isn’t the case, and sometimes because recruits join of their own free will, pacifists like myself can mistakenly attribute to them the evils of the wars in which they fought. But their choice illustrates the very reason they are deserving of honor, since they knew the risks and faced the threat by their own volition. They believed in something that was worth a heavy sacrifice, and that belief moved them to act.

However, not everyone believes in the same things. For example, many Christians believe war should not be the primary means of conflict resolution and honoring fallen soldiers for them feels contradictory. In those cases, can a person still honor others who have followed their convictions to their graves?

As early as St. Stephen, Christians have been willing to die for what they believe in, often under circumstances they could have easily avoided. With all their heart, they committed to follow Jesus to the ends of the Earth, and sometimes the end of their lives. It is this same sense of loyalty and service that fuels many soldiers. Having this appreciation for the martyrs helps us understand what drives soldiers.

It is not beyond the imagination to be able to distinguish service and sacrifice from the expectation to kill our enemies. Soldiers and martyrs are very distinct from one another, but in some ways they are very alike. The hearts of martyrs and soldiers relate in some ways, even if what they do with their hands are very different. It is not beyond our means to honor soldiers’ willingness to sacrifice, even learn from it, without agreeing about the wars in which they fought. You can honor the warrior without necessarily honoring the war.

The question of respecting soldiers while being critical of war is incredibly timely. Memorial Day is supposed to be a solemn day of reflection. Christians reflect with prayer and fasting, not in self-indulgent feasts. When we mistreat Memorial Day with nonchalance or celebration, it does not go unnoticed. It tells those who do serve that their sacrifice will be glossed over (“dog-and-ponied up,” soldiers say) or slip by unobserved. We’ve been at war longer than ever before in our nation’s history. Soldiers and veterans are committing suicide at greater rates than we’ve ever recorded. It is an ominous indication that something has gone terribly wrong, and apathy multiplies the tragedy.

So, what can we do?

Break down the barriers between veteran and civilian. Go to the local VA Hospital or Vet Center and volunteer. You might hear some incredible stories of fallen friends and enemies that will make your heart sink (or soar). Those we memorialize should have names and faces.

Visit a national cemetery if you can. 3pm local time is the designated hour for reflection, but even five minutes is better than nothing. Find the time to remember those who gave up their lives for their friends and fellow citizens. Pray that their memories are not reduced to merely another cry for war.

Let service members dictate how their memories are articulated. Consider not asking them to stand and be recognized; their wartime service may have been traumatic. Take the time to approach them personally and ask how they would prefer to remember their service and have their memories shared.

Ask to see who in your extended family has military service, and learn more about their time in uniform. The familial connection may prove profound, but use caution and be sensitive to cues that suggest a memory is off limits.

As citizens of a kingdom that knows no boundaries, make this Memorial Day one that also celebrates our nation’s enemies who have died in war. Undo the dehumanization that so often occurs in combat by recognizing that there may be justifiable motivations they hold.

Honoring people and their service, even those who are no longer with us, helps shape a culture that cultivates people serious about their convictions and prepared to see them through. The sacrifices made in war are not the same as Christian sacrifices, but we can learn much from the self-subordination and commitment to a cause that soldiers embody.

Remembering is central to our two-thousand-year-old faith. Sometimes it is a chore, and sometimes it is a joy. For a great number of soldiers and veterans, the pain associated with remembering their fallen comrades is great, and the burden is heavy. Don’t force it upon their shoulders alone. More importantly, it is remembering that we perform at communion, which for many traditions is the central act of faith. By remembering those in our Body (especially soldiers, on Memorial Day) who are often marginalized by either their undesired elevation as heroes or their being a mere ornament to the Memorial Day parties, we are re-membering our dismembered body of Christ.

Logan Mehl-Laituri is the author of Reborn on the Fourth of July: The Challenge of Faith, Patriotism and Conscience (InterVarsity Press). 

41 Comments

85,058

Dude commented…

If somebody came into your office and flipped your desk, I doubt you would consider that non violent.If your goal is to look intelligent you need to use a consistent straw man. I mean paradigm.

Braelyn

60

Braelyn commented…

As a member of a Friends Church, I have the background of Quaker pacifism. I have also been taught by my dad and grandpa that "you shouldn't fight, but when you do, win".

Melissa Peters

1

Melissa Peters commented…

I have been
blessed to grow up in a military town (maybe not the same one my whole life as
is the nature of being a military brat) and I have come to value the importance
of the service these men and women take on. Both of my grandfathers and my
father each served at least 20 years in the Army and all of them are or were
Christian men. I do understand that it is hard to figure out how serving your
country fits into serving God since that is the priority and from which all
things in your life should derive. However, sometimes war isn't just violence.
Sometimes it's those troops bringing food, clothing, blankets, comfort, hope
and much more to those who lack the freedom to seek truth as us American often
take for granted (I've heard story upon story of this happening as many of the
members of my church are Army soldiers). And regardless of whether or not our
servicemen and women are Christian, many are taught through their service what
sacrifice looks like and I continually pray they one day they learn about the
ultimate sacrifice as well as any other country looking in on us. I am grateful
that we do have a strong group of men and women who are ready to defend should
our freedoms of loving Christ and proclaiming His name truly be attacked by
other countries. As for our freedoms being attacked within our own country,
that is a whole different debate for another time, but I would encourage
everyone to keep our political leaders who make the decisions regarding any
policy in our country in your prayers as they are the ones who decide when our
country goes to any war and why. I do appreciate the sacrifice our servicemen
and women make and the sacrifices their families make as well.

lasharae

3

lasharae commented…

The article explores the ideas of being loyal to God and country as it relates to war and service as a soldier. Members of the U.S. armed forces swear to an oath that places them in servitude to the interests of the country and the orders of commanding officers and of the president. The government is an institution with purely secular interests. Devotion to furthering those interests through violence clearly conflicts with devotion to Biblical principles which include the pursuit of peace with all men. There is a very clear difference between violence against people used to defend the interests of a secular nation and aggression used to maintain the spiritual integrity of the temple of God. Also, I hope all Christians can agree that none of us are worthy to swing a sword against anyone, but God has the authority to strike down any and every thing that offends him.

85,058

Virak_Mac commented…

I reject vehemently to the arrogance demonstrated by those who claim that soldiers alone brought me my civic freedoms.

Many of my freedoms were also brought to me by non-violent demonstrators and activists like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., and were defended by academics, lawyers, agitators and pastors, many of whom were themselves pacifists.

Who contributed more to my freedom: a black father suing for his daughter's right to attend a white school in the deep south or a young man with a gun shooting other young men in any one of our nation's many unjust, non-defensive military adventures?

To discount all other actors and give credit to only the violent is idolatrous; it's tantamount to choosing Peter's actions in the garden over Jesus', and it is another indication that our country -- and even our pastors -- have fully bowed their knee to the god of American militarism rather than to the Prince of Peace.

Will

10

Will replied to 's comment

You could argue that alongside that black father, you have the 82nd Airborne to thank for enforcing the desegregation of southern school districts. But I agree with your premise that freedom is preserved by many actors.

Please log in or register to comment

Log In