Can You Lose Your Salvation?

Columnist Kurt Willems showcases both sides of the argument and seeks to lay a common ground.

Many of us wonder about our status before God. Does God love us? Does our love for God play into what it means to be accepted by God? Does God allow us to make our own choices—even to reject Christ’s love?

These questions often lead us to ask: Can a person lose their salvation?

Of course, two broad schools of thought emerge in theological discourse on this.

Calvinism

On one end of the spectrum are the 5.5-point Calvinists. (I'm not really sure what the extra .5 is all about.) Mark Driscoll—and basically most of the Gospel Coalition folks—uphold this view. This group of thinkers believes that God not only preordains all things—yep, every last event in world history—but that God ordains some to eternal life and some to eternal torment. They would contend that all people deserve eternal torment and that, therefore, God ordaining some for eternal life demonstrates His infinite mercy and wisdom.

Let’s be fair to this perspective. The individuals holding to it don’t believe evangelism is null and void (as many on the free will end of the spectrum often accuse). Rather, they believe that the truly elect will hear the message—through evangelistic efforts—and will awaken to their right standing before the Father. Evangelism matters here because we are viewed as God's heralds used to summon sinners into their electness, and those who persistently refuse to believe the message must not be elect. (See the first two videos embedded in this column to learn more about this view from Mark Driscoll, the second of which describes the contrast between the two theological views fairly well.)

Free-Will Theists

On the other side of the spectrum are the free-will theists who believe human choice cooperates with the wooing of God toward salvation. In other words, we are lost in our sinful condition without Christ but, through God’s grace, we have been enabled to rise above our sinfulness to freely choose or reject Jesus Christ as Lord.

This camp (which I have always identified with, even in my more “conservative” days) holds that we can have absolute assurance of our standing with God through the process of sanctification. The more we know God, experience the Spirit, and follow Jesus, the more assurance we have that we are in fact “in Christ” and therefore part of the “elect.”

But, let’s add one more interesting twist to all this.

Many in the free-will group are convinced that the way we’ve appropriated the words “elect,” “predestined” and all the attendant others used in this debate have been filtered through an individualistic lens. In other words, the more I read the New Testament through the lens of “community,” the more I come to think the “elect” is synonymous with “the people of God.” The Church is the elect of God! Individuals are invited to join in that “elect-ness” that indeed was “predestined.”


Think about it. God always knew that He would “elect” a special people. It started with Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Moses and traveled all the way through time to Jesus Himself—and then moved into the body of Jesus, the Church. In this view, you are not elect;we are the elect.

In the free-will theist's view, an individual can choose to remove him or herself from amongst the elect (people of God) by choosing the broad road of destruction and their blatant refusal to follow and even believe in Jesus. We need enough humility to not “guess” who those “unsaved” people are because God’s grace and wisdom transcend our categories. (See the last two videos embedded in this column to learn the free-will theists position from Greg Boyd, with Paul Eddy.)


Some people settle this matter by claiming that both perspectives are taught in the Bible—therefore, the truth lies somewhere in the middle. Personally, such an approach doesn’t satisfy what I see in the Scriptures. Certainly there are “problem texts” for both Calvinists and free-will theists. Additionally, we need the humility to admit that we will never know the full truth this side of God’s renewed creation.

With that stated, to live in the middle might serve as a copout from having to wrestle deeply with the biblical story and the God who is portrayed there within.

Ultimately, I believe that God grants humanity absolute freedom to embrace or disgrace the opportunity for union with the divine. You may disagree. We all belong at the same table, breaking the bread and drinking the wine that serves as a signpost of our shared salvation to come when our Lord returns. What we believe about the details must always be trumped by our common hope in resurrection.

38 Comments

85,364

Brandon commented…

I appreciate that you make your argument with the Bible; that's the place to go for all spiritual knowledge. And I agree with these verses. It is God's will that all people given to Christ will remain in him and that all who have believed will have eternal life. But saadly, in this world, God's will is not done by all people, and God's will is not done in all places. Don't get me wrong, the believer should never fall away, as this is grossly opposed to God's will for salvation, but people can sin, though it is God's will that we not sin, and people can choose worldly ways, even though it is God's will that we shouldn't. The Bible says in John 5:24 "Whoever hears my word and believes Him who sent me has eternal life and will not be condemned; he has crossed over from life to death." From this we know that all who hear and believe are saved. They don't just think they are saved. They are saved. If it is true that one who falls away from the church was never saved, then that means we can fool ourselves into believing we are saved, and then their will always be the burning question, "Am i truly among the elect, or am I destined to fall away by the will of God to be a warning to other Christians to remain faithful?" But if we count God's grace being upon all people, drawing them to him, the saved Christian has no reason to doubt his salvation unless he should choose to reject God willfully.

jake hawney

108

jake hawney commented…

The passage from John 5:24 talks about hearing the gospel preached, which the Calvinist would say that the proclamation of the gospel is what causes the regeneration of the elect. Those who are saved by faith and who repent of their sin and turn from it will persevere to the end and need not worry about being saved. It is those who do not repent, do not turn to God, and do not submit to the lordship of Christ that will "fall away" from the faith as evidence of them not being a part of the elect. I have no doubt that I am of the elect because of the life-change, repentance, and continued perseverance in faith that will last until my dying breath.

It is God's will that none that are given to Christ will fall away. So is our will stronger than God's will? If God wills and decrees something to happen, are we in position to stop it?

I affirm that all who hear and believe are saved, but the disagreement is, how do we believe? Does faith find it's origin in us or in God? Ephesians 2 says that it is a gift from God and that gift is what saves us. That would mean that not all have the capacity for faith, why? Because we are dead in our transgressions and slaves to sin. We need God to save us and regenerate us unto life.

Again, thanks for your response. I gotta close up shop and call it a day. We will agree to disagree. All I know is that we who call on the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, and turn from our sins and bow to his sovereignty are co-heirs of eternal life. Preach the word brother and study the scriptures hard.

85,364

Anonymous commented…

Given other key issues of scripture and the idea that there are often 2 ways or truths to the subject I have since under grad days believed that God at times will deal with his people differently. It is at least true from my reading that God can and will Change His mind. Maybe I want to believe in free will becausethis will give me some control over my life. There I go again with the issue of who is going to control my life.What ever the true Theology, God has the last say in the matter.Thank you Kurt. Corky Riley

85,364

Anonymous commented…

This sight is a welcome change from the usual Christian vs. Atheist Garbage on the internet. Real thoughtful discussion, not slander of belief

Jeff Cook

23

Jeff Cook commented…

How about Compatibilism?

Please log in or register to comment

Log In