Is Missions About Words or Deeds?

Our generation has made social justice the focus of missions. But have we forgotten Jesus?

I really enjoyed a column by Brad Greenberg (of The God Blog) a few weeks back in the Wall Street Journal's “Houses of Worship” column. The piece, entitled “How Missionaries Lost Their Chariots of Fire,” took a look at the trends in Christian missions in recent years—most notably the shift among younger evangelicals from proselytizing and preaching to doing more service and social justice-oriented work as mission. A shift in focus from words to deeds.

Evangelical youth now hold the term “missionary” at arm’s length, afraid of the colonialist connotations of the word. They prefer being involved in “social justice” under the auspices of a more generalized Christian sense of charity rather than operating under anything resembling (groan) “soul winning.”

Greenberg cites such popular organizations as Invisible Children, an ostensibly Christian social justice organization whose media kit states that its founders “believe in Christ, but do NOT want to limit themselves in any way.”

Greenberg, who notes that “Christians today typically travel abroad to serve others, but not necessarily to spread the gospel,” ultimately concludes that as much as abandoning the colonialist undertones and “vacationary” short-term reputation of evangelical missions is a good thing, we have to remember that both actions and words are necessary in missions.

He writes:

"Spreading Christianity through deeds alone aligns with a quote attributed to St. Francis of Assisi: 'Preach the Gospel always, and if necessary, use words.' But research suggests that non-Christians often miss the message without the words.

"A 2006 study by Calvin College’s Kurt Ver Beek found 'little or no difference' in the spiritual response between two groups of Hondurans—one which had its homes rebuilt by missionaries who did not proselytize and the other by local NGOs. Intuition would suggest as much. Unless foreigners explain that they are motivated to help by their religious beliefs, locals may be grateful for the new home but they should not be expected to connect dots that they may not even know exist.

"The reality is the Church should be doing both: serving the needy and spreading the gospel. This is what makes the humanitarian work of Christians different than that of the American Red Cross. Both are motivated by the desire to help others, but Christians are spurred by that Jesus thing."

Props to Greenberg for highlighting this important point—that in our desire to move away from the ills of “old school” missions thinking we don’t throw the baby (preaching the Gospel) out with the bathwater (colonialism, etc). Sadly, we  pendulum-prone evangelicals have a hard time with these both/and scenarios—always inclined to correct the ills of one thing by a wholesale replacement of it with something equally full of its own ills.

I’m all for social justice. I’m passionate about it. Christians have to be serving people and loving them not just in word but in deed. But man, if I hear another well-fed, TOMS-wearing evangelical kid quote St. Francis (“preach the Gospel always, and if necessary, use words”) one more time as a justification for their unwillingness to utter a word to anyone about Christ as the one true hope, I don’t know what I’ll do.

It’s an ongoing debate in missiology: Should missionaries in foreign countries prioritize meeting physical needs (food, water, social justice, development) before they preach the Gospel, or should evangelism always be given primacy?

To me, the debate is silly. Can’t we do both simultaneously? Can’t we serve others and meet their circumstantial needs while at the same time telling them about Jesus? Yes, we should be in Africa building water wells, or in Haiti building schools, but what’s the harm in mentioning along the way that we are Christians acting as the Church, loving the world because God loved it?

I’m not sure missions could ever be too focused on deeds—unless it is at the expense of the equally important words of truth that people need to hear. I hope my generation figures out a way to emphasize both.

Brett McCracken is a blogger and author of the upcoming book Hipster Christianity
(Baker Books). His love for the new Arcade Fire album borders on idolatry. This article originally appeared on his blog and is used by permission.

59 Comments

Jeff Goins

228

Jeff Goins commented…

Right. I get that. But even the language we use (e.g. "pendulum swinging...") betrays a certain dichotomous view, I think.

MattandSteph Bell

9

MattandSteph Bell commented…

What I am saying is yes, we -as the body of Christ, Church, Christians in general, and even I, can often fall into living 'dichotomously'- as you put it... thats why I purposefully used the phrase "pendulum swinging"
... Although my point is that: our 'walk' should not have to be that way.

Because again "if we get down to it the gospel presented in entirety is going to 'serve' and represent being the 'hands and feet of Jesus no matter what.' "

85,389

hopefulmourning commented…

I agree with almost all of what has been written above...I am a "missionary" in africa and work with a great organization that is run by Africans. The work that we do is all through local churches in urban slums and we focus a lot of time and energy investing in Pastors of local churches who are motivated by a vision for integrating solid bible teaching with responsible social action. The ideal is often elusive, even though our intentions are good. One of the most frustrating parts of our work is the pressure we feel from western donors to get "results". The results they want are almost always unrealistic, unsustainable, and often times detrimental to the long term welfare of the communities we are serving in. I could give a dozen examples from the past 12 months alone, but I don't think that would be most beneficial for the discussion right now. Bottom line...God is at work all over the world through all kinds of "missionaries", local ones and international ones, even short term ones...sometimes.. :) . Great Article, much needed

85,389

Taso commented…

Fantastic article. We are Christians should be bold in sharing our faith with others. We have received this gift of grace. It would be downright selfish not to share the words of Christ with others who haven't yet received Christ as their personal savior. How will others know about Jesus unless we tell them? Each of us as Christians had people in our lives telling us about Jesus at one point in time. This led us to then believe in Jesus ourselves. We need to share the gospel with others, just as it was shared with us. I thank the Lord that he put people in my life to tell me about Christ. We should be fearless in sharing our faith. And if we share our faith with love and compassion, others will want to follow Jesus because they will want to receive this wonderful gift of forgiveness of sins that we have received.

85,389

FEBC commented…

Yes, great post! It's funny how there is this ongoing dichotomy between word and deed. Jesus and his disciples all preached, healed, and served. Missions and evangelism is loving people, and showing/telling them the reason and source of that love.

Please log in or register to comment

Log In