Expand

Is There Hope After Suicide?

Tackling the tough spiritual questions about this difficult tragedy.

I was in Atlanta to lead a Bible conference at a church. I was alone in the pastor's home, sitting on the couch in the den working on my sermon for the morning. The phone call startled me; the phone caller stunned me. “Bryce did what?” I sank back into the couch. Our Christian leader, friend and brother Bryce Teller* had committed suicide.

We were shocked and saddened; we were concerned and confused; we were bewildered, not knowing what to believe. So many questions were being asked that should be addressed and answered.

Is Suicide a Sin?

The first question: Is suicide a sin? And the answer is yes. The dictionary defines suicide as "the taking of one's life voluntarily and intentionally." It is the taking of a life in a manner forbidden by God. It is murder—self-inflicted murder, but murder nonetheless—and God's Word states, "You shall not murder" (Exodus 20:13).

Furthermore, life—all life—belongs to God. "In Him we live and move and have our being" (Acts 17:28). We don't own life. God owns life, and He lends it to us at His pleasure to be lived for our pleasure and His glory. Life is not our own to destroy, so the destruction of life by suicide is a sin.

But suicide is not the unforgivable sin. Some have taught that suicide is unforgivable, but such teaching is wrong. Homicide is not the unforgivable sin. If that were the case, the apostle Paul would not be forgiven, for by his own testimony he informs us that he was guilty of murder (Acts 26:11; see Acts 9:1; 10:21). Homicide is not the unforgivable sin; nor is suicide the unforgivable sin. The senseless taking of human life is wrong, but it is not unforgivable, even if the life taken is one's own.

When Jesus died, He paid the penalty in full for all of our sins—past, present and future. In Him, our sins are removed from us as far as the east is from the west. God did not say, "I will forgive you as long as your sins are not too great or as long as you get around to confessing everything you did was wrong." If that were the case, we would all be condemned. But the Bible declares, "Therefore, there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus" (Romans 8:1).

Can a Christian Commit Suicide?

The second question: Can a Christian commit suicide? And the answer is yes. Christians can commit all kinds of sins. Christians are not perfect. In this life, we have not been fully sanctified, finally glorified. We still possess remnants of our old sinful nature, and in this nature resides the potential for every kind of sin. We have the capacity to contemplate crimes that we never commit. But even the contemplation is itself a sin.

Do you remember how our Lord Jesus expanded the meaning of the Ten Commandments with his own interpretation? For instance, the seventh commandment: “You shall not commit adultery.” Jesus said that if you lust after a woman in your heart, if in your own mind you commit adultery, you are guilty of breaking that commandment (Matthew 5:27-28). The sixth commandment: “You shall not murder.” Jesus said that if you are so angry you want to kill, if you cry to your brother, "You fool!" and you desire to destroy his life, then by that very desire you have broken the commandment (Matthew 5:21-22).

It is wrong for one to take his own life, but it is also wrong for one to contemplate taking his own life. And who of us has not in a moment of despair or frustration or self-pity contemplated, at least momentarily, the taking of his or her own life?

The apostle Peter walked on water, and as long as he kept his eyes focused on the Lord Jesus Christ, he continued to walk on the water. But when he took his eyes away from the Lord and began to look at the treacherous waves around him, he began to sink (Matthew 14:29-30).

And yet sometimes in those deep waters we forget. Our faith, which is real, is nonetheless really weak. And the fogs of despair, discouragement and depression become so thick that we cannot see the face of the Lord Jesus. So we need to pray with the man at the foot of the Mount of Transfiguration, “I do believe; help me overcome my unbelief” (Mark 9:24).

What Happens to the Person Who Commits Suicide?

The third question: What happens to the person who commits suicide? Well, that depends. What happens to any person who dies, regardless of how he dies? If that person is an unbeliever, that person goes to hell. If that person is a believer, that person goes to heaven. If the person who commits suicide is not a Christian, that person goes to hell. If the person who commits suicide is a Christian, that person goes to heaven.

Are Others to Blame When One Commits Suicide?

The fourth question: Are others to blame when one commits suicide? The answer is no. No doubt many will feel guilty in this situation, as many always do. Why were we not more sensitive? Why were we not more caring? Why did we not encourage him more? What should I have done? It's all my fault. No, it's not. God makes each of us responsible moral agents, and each of us is accountable to Him for our decisions and the actions that flow from those decisions. This does not mean, however, that others are without blame and without guilt. Yes, we ought to be more sensitive and more caring and more supportive and certainly more prayerful. There is much blame to bear, and we ought to confess our failures before God, but we are not responsible for another's decision. There is a big difference between failing to support someone who is suffering and the decision of the sufferer to take his own life; and while we may be guilty of one, we are not guilty of the other.

Is God Still in Control at the Point of Suicide?

The fifth question: Is God still in control at the point of suicide? The answer is yes—God is still in control. God is in control of all, or God is not in control at all. If there is one exception, God is not sovereign. We may be tempted to say, “God was loving enough, but God was not powerful enough to stop that tragedy.” Or we may be tempted to say, “God was powerful enough, but God was not loving enough to stop that tragedy.” No, we must affirm both the love and the power of an all-wise God. God is loving—He's kind; He's tender; He's merciful; He's compassionate; He's powerful; He's mighty; He's sovereign—and death by suicide is an awful, horrible, terrible tragedy. We affirm both the reality of a great God and the reality of a terrible tragedy, but beyond that we affirm that the great God was in control of the terrible tragedy.

Do we have questions? Of course! We want to ask a thousand whys, don't we? Why did God allow it to happen? Why did He not stop it? We want to know why God allowed sin to come into the world in the first place, don't we? God has answers for our thousand questions. He may give us an answer, or He may not give us an answer, but that does not alter the fact that God knows the answer. God knows what He is doing.

Do God's Promises Still Apply to the Person Who Commits Suicide?

The sixth question: Do God's promises still apply to the person who commits suicide? And the answer is yes. All of God's promises still apply to the person who commits suicide, for don't you see that all of God's promises in Christ are "yes" and in Him "Amen" (see 2 Corinthians 1:20). Suicide does not contravene the promises of God. Suicide does not place one outside the parameters of the promises of God. Suicide does not make null and void the promises of God.

What about the promise of Romans 8:28 (KJV): "All things (even suicide] work together for good to them that love God." Yes, even that promise applies!

And What Should We Do?

The seventh question: And what should we do? How should we respond in the face of this teaching from God's Word? We should cry. We should cry out in pain. The Bible says to weep with those who weep (Romans 12:15). This is a tragedy that calls for tears.

We should cry out in pain, and we should cry out in prayer and we should cry out in praise. But most of all, we can praise God for being God, for being the God He really is, for being the God whom we can trust even in the face of such tragedies. He is the God to whom we can turn with all of our questions and heartache and pain, and He is the God who has already triumphed for us in Jesus Christ.

If you are desperate or despondent, do not believe that your sadness disqualifies you from Jesus' love or dismays your Savior. Instead, recognize that He is the Savior of the disconsolate and loves to call the sorrowful to His embrace.

Taken from The Hardest Sermons You'll Ever Have to Preach by Bryan Chapell. Copyright © 2011 by Bryan Chapell. Used by permission of Zondervan,

*Individual names have been changed as an expression of care for the family.

68 Comments

85,229

Rachel commented…

if you are fully sanctified, then why wasn't your comment perfected? shouldn't it be?

Christopher Legan

2

Christopher Legan commented…

Your hubris is comical. What do you know?

James

2

James commented…

WOW! This is blasphemy. I wouldn't want to be in your shoes on judgment day. Telling people they'll be forgiven if they commit suicide. Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is the unpardonable sin. Denying the power thereof. Which means when one commits suicide their doing just that. Their saying Jesus your not big enough or you don't have a enough power to deliver me from committing suicide. I've been there I know. I was going to commit suicide when my girlfriend left me 30 years ago and that's when I got Saved. I've been on fire for Jesus ever since. And I've had cancer three times and Jesus Healed me. And every time I went into surgery I was never afraid for He was with me. I rebuke you for lying to people about this subject. And I pray God puts His fear into you for deceiving people. Just because one claims their a Christian does not make them one. When a person becomes Born Again his trust is totally in Jesus no matter what. Saul was not a Christian and neither was Judas. There are billions in this world that think their are Christians that have believed a lie and have been deceived because they no not The Word Of God. Jesus said they honor me with their lips but their hearts are far from me.

Lyle Goldbaum

1

Lyle Goldbaum commented…

Did jesus not say if your hand commits a sin cut it from you if your eye causes you to sin pluck it out i wonder how many who preach actually follow thier own beliefs suicide is a mental disorder does a sane person just decide to committ suicide does a sane person just decide to murder no theres allways a sickness involved so if ones has a mental disorder then does that mean you cannot enter heaven i think not jesus died for all our sins not just one or two but all ok yes the unforgivable sin well if your a christian you cannot committ this sin to deny our hollysprit is to deny god and doing so means you were never a christian therefore a christian with a mental dissorder cannot be held accountable for this sin of self murder therefore is forgiven funny how many judge others and not them selves i judge myself all the time and i thank god for letting jesus forgive our sins DO YOU or are you just a christian by word of mouth actions speak loudest just ask jesus he was the master of action it saddens me when people try to tell others whats righ and whats wrong are you going to hold yourself accountable if your wrong will you accept the consequences just my two cents worth

Please log in or register to comment

Log In