The Personality Paradox of Jesus

Meek and mild, or tough and bold? Will the real Jesus please stand up?

Gentle Jesus, meek and mild. It’s a distortion, but a pervasive one. Such is the power of song and poetry. It’s dangerous, however, because it is simply not true.

There were times when He chose to be meek. But He was never mild. He was born into conflict and remained in it His whole life. He jousted with the devil in the desert; He frequently exchanged words with the religious groups of the day. He risked life and reputation by spending time with housefuls of tax collectors and in the company of known prostitutes. He was not condemned to die on the cross because He was mild. He was sent there because He was wild.

Wild enough to turn over the tables of those who were fleecing the faithful as they came to the temple to worship. Wild enough to embrace the hated neighbors (Samaritans). Wild enough to touch the unclean leper.

Jesus was meek and wild. Are you comfortable with that paradox? It is a challenge to our normal either/or mindset. Is it possible to believe that Jesus’ life was full of both/and tensions? What does Scripture tell us?

He worked with His father as a carpenter. He fell asleep in boats during storms. He ate, He wept, He cried out in anguish as the time of His trial approached. He was moved with compassion for His friends Lazarus, Mary and Martha.

Jesus was very human.

But Jesus was divine. His earthly mother Mary was impregnated by the Divine. Jesus was the Son of God. He talked to His Father constantly.

The record of His life speaks of His authority over the elements of nature. He walked on the water. He rebuked the wind and the raging waters, and they became calm.

He rose from the dead, was seen by more than 500 witnesses and extended His nail-pierced hands to the doubting disciple Thomas.

How do we reconcile His divinity and His humanity? How could they coexist? If we allow for the reality of the human/divine in the person of Jesus, what other tensions might we allow?

Jesus seemed to care little for popular opinion, warning healed people not to gossip about what had happened to them, risking the wrath of the whole city of Jericho by visiting the tax collector whom everyone hated and musing that some of the crowds following were spiritual thrill-seekers from a “wicked generation.”

This prophetic confrontation was a hallmark of Jesus’ words and deeds.

Are you ready to confront systems of thought with the challenge of the life and words of Jesus? Are you willing to express an unpopular opinion and face the anger and misrepresentation of your motives that will result? Can you live with the tension of seeking to balance that mental toughness with a gracious kind-ness to people seeking to make sense of their lives and circumstances? It is vital that you do. Impatience and a judgmental attitude are the curse of the prophet who doesn’t internalize the wisdom of the whole of Jesus’ life. Are you willing to embrace the paradox of grace and justice?

Jesus was tender, Jesus was tough

Jesus found it impossible to ignore sickness, often making His first task the healing of the sick. He healed two blind men and took the risk of touching the unclean leper as He was moved with compassion in response to their heartfelt requests.

Jesus was a tenderhearted man.

But what kind of toughness did it take to hear people attribute your miracles to the devil, to walk through crowds ready to throw you over a cliff, or to endure the lashes that should never have been given to an innocent man?

What kind of man would die the slow death of suffocation to which hanging from the cross sentenced you?

What kind of man would return to a group of men that had betrayed Him and make the most verbal traitor the leader of His new community? What kind of man would step nimbly around the verbal traps laid by His opponents, seeking to get Him to disagree with the law of Moses or the tax laws of the day?

Not a weak man, not a timid man, not a man who lacked principles and not a man whose life was held captive by the opinions of others.

Jesus was tough because He was compassionate. One led to the other. He had come to take captivity captive. He had come to release the oppressed.

If we only ever speak of the tender Jesus, we will slip into sentimentality. If we only ever speak of the Jesus who challenged human hearts, we will end up sounding shrill. If we speak of both, we can bring words that will sustain and nourish a spiritually hungry, weary and brokenhearted generation.

Jesus in the ‘hood, Jesus in the ‘burbs

With several fishermen and Simon the Zealot among His disciples, Jesus was in touch with the ordinary workingman. But He also had a tax collector, a middle-class man, in the disciples’ ranks.

He also got along with the elite of His day. Nicodemus, a member of the ruling council of the Jews, visited privately to talk. Jesus had friends among the rich, including Joseph of Arimathea, who purchased the place where He was briefly buried. Joseph was also a member of the Council and was prominent enough to be granted an audience with Pilate.

Our vision of Jesus as the champion of the poor or the author of godly free enterprise will always need to be tempered by His unwillingness to conform to labels and neat categories. The hand that touched the leper, blessed the child and washed the disciples’ feet was also extended to the rulers of His day.

Jesus was wronged at some point by every section of society, but He kept on loving in a relentless fashion, aware of their imperfection, but believing the truth could set them free and restore them to their original purpose: loving God and loving their neighbor.

Jesus, in the world but not of it

Jesus did a lot of very ordinary things amid the miracles, parables and verbal dust-ups with spiritually anxious teachers of the law. He went out with some of the disciples while they did their work and actually helped them catch more fish than normal. He cooked breakfast for His disciples. He washed their feet. He visited people’s homes a lot—even when it was not expedient in terms of His reputation, Zacchaeus the tax collector being a case in point.

At other times He had conversations that were likely to attract rebuke. He talked alone to a woman who was immoral and a member of a despised group.

It is clear that Jesus was not “of the world.” He had not embraced its way of thinking. But His life is a severe provocation to those who would ask us to contain our lives in a Christian enclave, protected from this world and cut off from the mundane contact with people that allows communication, signals acceptance and is sometimes countercultural because it crosses boundaries of class, gender, race and creed.

Ask yourself these questions: Do I spend time with my neighbors or work colleagues or friends doing mundane, ordinary things? Do I eat with them, talk to them about sports, discuss the nature of our work, reflect on the news together? Do I believe that from their growing trust will flow the chance to talk about Jesus, life and eternity, maybe next week, maybe next year?

Living with the paradoxes in the life of Jesus doesn’t involve compromise. You’re not being asked to ignore parts of it. You are being asked to take it all seriously. It won’t always be understood when you do.

But that’s the challenge of following Jesus.

Dave Roberts is the author of Following Jesus (Relevant Books). This article originally appeared in RELEVANT.



Anonymous commented…

Grace and Justice.

Romans 3:26 shows this comparison so beautifully when speaking of God. He sent Jesus (the image of God), "so that he He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus."

He showed He is just not by taking away the penalty of sin, but instead sending Jesus to pay the price.

He showed his grace as the justifier - the one who provides the means for us to be put into right standing with Himself.

Grace and Justice - they meet at the cross. Aren't you glad?


R Lubbers commented…

The article does a good job of enumerating some of the paradoxes and "apparent paradoxes" in Jesus' life. However, I noticed two things I'd like to push back on.

First, the illustration at the top of the article is not helpful. It is not illustrative of the way Jesus died and it seems to buy into at least two stereotypical ideas: (1) that dying on the cross is the "weak side" of Jesus; (2) that true strength is the equivalent of physical strength (as illustrated by the pumping-iron-physique of Jesus in the picture).

Second, the author seems to be using the resurrection (as well as miracles) as "biblical proofs" of Jesus' divinity. Is this how you really want to explain the resurrection? As a proof of Jesus' divinity? No, the awesome thing about the resurrection is that the man Jesus was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father. Not to prove his divinity. But to validate his vicarious, human life and death. If Jesus rose from the dead merely because he was divine, then he's not the "first fruits" of those who sleep. Volumes have been written on this... I suggest T.F. Torrance and N.T. Wright for starters... But I hope my short paragraph makes the point.

Because paradoxes are paradoxical, they are not easily categorized nor easily explained. And sometimes it's best not to try.


saneman commented…

He risked life and reputation by spending time with housefuls of tax collectors and in the company of known prostitutes.

hehe come on people...

jonathan Keck


jonathan Keck commented…

Cheers. I am tired of people portraying Jesus Jesus as a muscle clad, arnoldschwarzenized, machine-gun wielding, dinosaur riding tough guy. He was tough, yes. But I was no UFC fighter. READ MORE


Karina commented…

I always had difficulties with relating to Jesus and following His example aswell as understanding the many paradoxes in His teaching and life.It was only after I had the courage to leave behind a relationship that obviously wasn't working out and leaving me confused that I started to look elsewhere for answers to how I could find True Peace including in the teachings of Buddha, Hinduism and New Age teachings and the remarkable meeting with my Guardian Angel who is in every way just as good a friend as Jesus in Truth and has always been there loving me unconditionally and supporting me since I was born and before I came here.

I highly recommend everyone who is having difficulty in relating to God or with their life in any way to connect with their Guardian Angel who is just waiting to help and serve you -- angels are truly wondrously beautiful beings and divine diplomats that can help answering any questions relating to God and Jesus by ironing out any communication difficulties and between you and God aswell as making your wishes known to Him and surprising the heck out of you with their gentleness guidance.humour and miraculous signs.
Absolutely everyone has at least one they can always call on (the connection is already hard-wired into you body mind soul temple by God when you come here because they regulate all the functions of a growing child's mind soul and it's body's life support systems) and there are some very good books to help one connect with one's Guardian Angel through meditation if you wish and though it takes time skill and perseverance to develop and establish the relationship it's absolutely well worth it in the end.

My own search led me eventually on the mystical path within. What I discovered there was the Eternal Truth that is Universal that is known in many parts of the globe as I AM Which is God Himself within one's own heart. This is truth is presented even in the most ancient of Indian holy scriptures or Vedas of hinduism which is the oldest living faith in the world preceding even christianity..

Eventually I had a revelation of the Heavenly Father Himself Who Is I AM Itself and Whose True Identity ..and this IS going to ROCK the world one day and bring East Middle, India/Far East and West closer than they've ever been nad perhaps even bring about world peace under One Father Who is Actually The First and Eternal Father of all gods and creatures who have ever been or ever will be as the Supreme Reality or Truth Itself and The Holy Spirit is eternally One with Him and is none other than the Virgin Mary the Great Divine Mother or Sophia Who is known as Divine Breath Wisdom in the OT and Shekina by the Jews or Shakti by the Hindus Who is equal in power to the Lord but remains mainly hidden to us according to His Will depending on one's readiness for a deeper revelation, but S-He can also be invoked just the same as the other members of the Trinity ..

So The Heavenly Father YHWH Elohim is none other than the most Ancient Creator of the Universe in the Hindu Trinity Lord Brahma (The other two extremely ancient gods are Vishnu and Shiva)..John 1:1 and the YajurVeda Creation Myth are identical: "In the beginning was the Word...".Mindblowing really !
In India ages ago because there was a cosmic feud between the Gods of the Trinity the Heavenly Father's Cult was expelled and there are only a couple of temples dedicated to Him there while He was worshipped exetsnsively throughout the rest of the ancient world with his Consort ;-)

There is evidence that Abraham and Sarah were settled in India (Abraham=Brahm) and there are even tribes in India who have been recognized as descendants of the lost tribes of Israel and been approached by the State of Israel with the invitation to be naturalized and absorbed within the Jewish nation. Jesus'' presence in Tibet Ladakh and Kashmir in India has also been documented as many will be aware of but I haven't really delved into it so deeply.

.My mind still boggles at these facts.YHWH Elohim THF truly Is the Universal Creator God Himself I was utterly shocked to my core when He showed me these things through His Grace.

Another thing I would recommend to people which might help strengthen their relationship with God is to obtain a copy of the New Testament translated from the Aramaic containing the original words Jesus spoke which carry a power meaning and beauty so mindblowing you'll be amazed and stunned and come closer to Jesus' true spirit than ever before.The King James Version translated from the Greek is heavily diluted in it's meaning and power in comparison.

The AENT Bible and "Prayers to the Cosmos" by Neil Douglas-Klotz are highly recommended for Jesus' original words which will literally blow your socks off !!
I hope this is of help and inspiration to anyone who reads it.Peace and Blessings !

Please log in or register to comment

Log In